HELENA, Mont. — Feb 12, 2018, 4:51 PM ET

Federal judge upholds Montana prohibition on most robocalls


A federal judge has upheld the constitutionality of Montana's law prohibiting most robocalls after a challenge by a political consulting firm that sought to do business in the state.

Victory Processing LLC of Grand Rapids, Michigan, and Dave Deshaw filed a complaint last year arguing the state law violated their right to free speech and hampered their ability to convey political messages to Montana voters.

U.S. District Judge Charles Lovell ruled Friday the U.S. Supreme Court has repeatedly ruled individuals are not required to welcome unwanted speech into their homes and the government may protect that freedom.

The ruling also notes the state law allows recorded calls to be made if a live operator first receives the recipient's permission or if there is a prior business relationship between the parties.

News - Federal judge upholds Montana prohibition on most robocalls

RRelated Posts


  • helicohunter

    So fed up with those credit card calls. I report every one of them and I do know that some have been slapped with huge fines.

  • Dukedaddy

    In my opinion, all telemarketer calls should be banned. The vast majority of them are from scam artists.

    If the phone companies don't have the technology to stop it then it's time for them to invest in some R&D and create a system to stop it.

    If tech companies can invent self driving cars and booster rockets that land themselves vertically, why can't someone invent a way to block telemarketers.

  • Quilter Mom

    I'm really sick of getting fake police charity calls. A voice asks for someone who is not there, you say wrong number and the tape flips over to a spiel about some XYZ police something or other. We asked local sheriff's staff and they said most of them are fakes. Anonymous calls should be automatically screen out for everybody. They should be required to get your PERMISSION for junk phone calls, emails or snailmail. Its rediculous how much money is wasted by these scams.

  • KlintzDisqus

    Certain charities are allowed to robocall you despite your wishes not to be interrupted in the sanctity of your own home.

    For now at least, the robocalls to your cellphone are mostly prohibited/filtered out by the cellular providers. Who wants to spend their own money/minutes being bombarded by calls you never wanted to get in the first place? Cellular providers know people would dump them if they let the robocalls go through unlimited.